Such uses require quantitative modelling of human reliability. It describes an approach to human reliability analysis hra and its application to a test case. Post event human decision errors, operator action treetime reliability correlation. Bley, john wreathall, and erasmia lois prepared by sandia national laboratories albuquerque, new mexico 87185 and livermore, california 94550. The human factors risk manager hfrm software suite is an integrated set of human factors tools designed to support a wide range of analyses that are typically carried out in safety critical systems in the healthcare, chemical processing, aviation, power generation and other industries. Such analyses generally comprise human reliability assessment hra in.
Pdf human reliability analysis accounting for human actions. The hrp is a security and safety reliability program designed to ensure that individuals who occupy positions affording access to certain materials, nuclear explosive devices, facilities, and programs meet the highest standards of reliability and physical and mental suitability. Two general classes of methods are those based on probabilistic risk assessment pra and those based on a cognitive theory of control. Reliability centered maintenance project managers guide executive summary hundreds of public and private sector organizations around the world have demonstrated that reliability centered maintenance rcm is consistently capable of significantly increasing asset performance by delivering value to owners, customers and stakeholders. An overview of human reliability analysis techniques in manufacturing operations chapter pdf available march 20 with 1,267 reads how we measure reads. Human reliability analysis accounting for human actions and external factors through the project life cycle. Human reliability analysis is one of the areas of probabilistic safety assessment psa that has direct applications outside the nuclear industry. Human reliability analysis hra is a comprehensive and structured methodology that applies qualitative and often also quantitative methods to assess the human contribution to risk.
Tasks may be related to equipment repair, equipment or system operation, safety actions, analysis, and other kinds of human actions that influence system performance. Iaea training course on safety assessment of npps to assist decision making. Smith idaho national laboratory battelle energy alliance idaho falls, id 83415 p. Still, patient safety has not improved significantly. Enre645 human reliability analysis 3 credits elective. The thesis focuses upon developments in human reliability analysis methods and data. Guidance on human factors safety critical task analysis 2011. Example fault tree analysis covers interactions manmachine o r system, explicit ly and implicitly, models human failures like failures of components, can help identify the most important consequences of human. Reliability engineering and system safety 41 1993 2547. A survey of databased human reliability analysis approaches.
Human reliability analysis hra webarchiv of the eth zurich. Collection and classification of human reliability data for. This regulation provides the policies and procedures to ensure that individuals who occupy positions affording unescorted access to certain nuclear materials, nuclear explosive devices, facilities and programs meet the. The consequences of unreliable behavior of information systems have become increasingly severe and have led to the desire for improved reliability. Human reliability assessment theory and practice crc. Human reliability studies seek to determine the trends of people to make mistakes in their performance. A new humanreliabilityanalysis method for aviation safety dwight p. Human reliability is the probability of humans conducting specific tasks with satisfactory performance. View human reliability analysis research papers on academia. It includes case studies and describes what a good scta looks like. Therefore, it helps effectively avoid and prevent human errors in industrial fields. To provide insights that may improve human performance. Organisations seeking to implement hra should choose the method best suited to their needs and capabilities. Nureg1842 evaluation of human reliability analysis methods.
Pdf handbook of human reliability analysis with emphasis. Today, utilities, research institutions, consulting firms, and the regulatory agency have found a common application of hra tools and probabilistic risk assessment pra. Chapter 2 shows basic reliability mathematics and concepts. Pdf an overview of human reliability analysis techniques. Pdf an overview of human reliability analysis techniques in. Home human reliability program handbook what is the hrp. This regulation provides the policies and procedures to ensure that individuals who occupy positions affording unescorted access to certain nuclear materials, nuclear explosive devices, facilities and.
An overview of the evolution of human reliability analysis. The aim is to support psa by extending the applicability of hra. Pdf phoenix a modelbased human reliability analysis. More specifically, hra consists in the application of a series of methods to determine how human performance can negatively impact a system, predict how often this. Human reliability analysis handbook of safety principles wiley. An overview of the evolution of human reliability analysis in. This is a list of characteristics of the people, the work and the organisation that influence human performance. Human performance can be affected by many factors such as age, state of mind, physical health, attitude, emotions, propensity. In order to support further the incorporation of human reliability data into psa, the.
Human reliability also known as human performance or hu is related to the field of human factors and ergonomics, and refers to the reliability of humans in fields including manufacturing, medicine and nuclear power. The standardized plant analysis risk human reliability analysis sparh method was developed to support development of plantspecific probabilistic risk analysis pra models for the us nuclear. Therefore, it helps effectively avoid and prevent human. This method was based on a human reliability analysis hra method called therp. Human reliability an overview sciencedirect topics. Introduction to reliability portsmouth business school, april 2012 2 after this, the reliability, rt, will decline as some components fail to perform in a satisfactory manner. Human reliability analysis lessons learned from the. No psa study can be regarded as complete and accurate without adequate incorporation of human reliability analysis hra. Draws upon reliability analysis, psychology, human factors engineering, and statistics, integrating elements of these fields within a systems framework. This document provides an outline to the scta process which is essentially a human reliability assessment. This article outlines how the model of accident causation that an organisation or individual holds can have an impact on the overall quality of an. There are many and varied methods available for hra, with some high hazard industries developing bespoke, industry focused methods.
With human factors focuses on human reliability during system design. The objective of a human reliability analysis is to evaluate the operators contribution to system reliability and. An overview of human reliability analysis techniques in manufacturing operations. For over ten years, a traditional human reliability analysis hra technique, the root cause analysis rca has been used in hospitals nationwide in an attempt to explain why these errors occur and what can be done to prevent them. Nuregcr1278, handbook of human reliability analysis with. Collection and classification of human reliability data. The human cognitive model not only makes a sound exposition of the generation process and mechanism of human erroneous actions but also improves the accuracy and credibility of human reliability analysis hra. Human reliability analysis research papers academia. Human reliability analysis hra human influence on operation of a system such as an npp regular operational actions, maintenance actions, such as inspection and repair, control of small disturbances, termination of an ongoing disturbance, as well as mitigation of its consequences. Human reliability assessment theory and practice crc press book. Human reliability analysis hra methodologies used in the. In this book the author shows how these objectives can be achieved by concentrating on human reliability issues during the design stage. The human factors risk manager a comprehensive tool for supporting human factors analyses. An overview of human reliability analysis techniques in.
Dennis bley buttonwood consulting, roger boyer nasa, johnson space center, andreas bye. Human reliability in information systems springerlink. Pdf fuzzy uncertainties in human reliability analysis. Human reliability analysis hra of a probabilistic safety assessment psa includes. Human congnitive reliability model for pra analysis.
The objectives of human reliability are to build reliability into the job, into the machine, and into the environment, and to let man perform naturally. The objective of a human reliability analysis is to. Review of human reliability assessment methods rr679. Human reliability analysis is an evolving field that addresses the need to account for human errors when. Human reliability analysis, office for nuclear regulation, onr, 20. Human reliability analysis methods for probabilistic safety assessment. Doe is amending its regulation concerning the human reliability program hrp. Human quantification techniques handbook of human reliability analysis therp nuregcr1278. This paper discusses the state of the art in the reliability analysis of human operators. Traditional hra techniques are limited as analysis tools.
Introduction to reliability university of portsmouth. An overview of human reliability analysis techniques in manufacturing operations valentina di pasquale, raffaele iannone, salvatore miranda and stefano riemma valentina di pasquale, raffaele iannone, salvatore miranda and stefano riemma. Human reliability analysis hra methodologies used in the canadian probabilistic safety assessment psa for external events hayat chatria, smain yalaouia, and yolande akla a canadian nuclear safety commission, ottawa, canada abstract. Modern technology has created a tendency to produce systems of greater capital cost, sophistication, complexity, and capacity. Methods of solving practical human reliability problems, the therp, slim, oat and sharp methods, performance shaping factors, human machine systems analysis, distribution of human performance and uncertainty bounds, skill levels, source of. Human reliability analysis methods and tools sciencedirect. Human reliability analysis in support of risk assessment. A separate paper in this conference provides the qualitative analysis overview of the phoenix a modelbased human reliability analysis hra methodology. This paper discusses the quantitative analysis aspect which rides on the three layers of the qualitative analysis crew response tree crt, human response model, performance influencing factors pifs, by first assigning values to the. An overview of the evolution of human reliability analysis in the context of probabilistic risk assessment john a. Objectives of human reliability analysis to ensure that the key human interactions are systematically identified, analyzed, and incorporated into the risk analysis in a traceable manner.
Dec 15, 2016 the human cognitive model not only makes a sound exposition of the generation process and mechanism of human erroneous actions but also improves the accuracy and credibility of human reliability analysis hra. Handbook of humanreliability analysis with emphasis on. Pdf a modelbased human reliability analysis methodology. Human reliability analysis methods for probabilistic. To quantify the probabilities of their success and failure. A variety of methods exist for human reliability analysis hra. Pdf a survey of databased human reliability analysis. Human reliability analysis methods for probabilistic safety. Oreilly, nrc project officer prepared for division of risk analysis and applications. Standardized plant analysis risk human reliability assessment. Human reliability analysis international atomic energy.
Human reliability analysis hra considering the human failure as an int egral part of a fault tree or event tree analysis. The goals defined by swain and guttmann 1983 in discussing the therp approach, one of the first hra methods developed, are still valid. Human reliability analysis office for nuclear regulation. Human reliability program handbook department of energy. Workshop information iaea workshop city, country xx xx month, year city, country xx xx month, year. A new human reliability analysis method for aviation safety dwight p. Analysing and measuring dependability without assessing human reliability is at best incomplete and at worst misleading human dependability not just at the sharp end, also maintenance crew, operator support, management teams, organisational personnel however still not part of core standards such as 61508 i. The nrc and industry have identified human reliability analysis hra as one of the challenges with modeling flex in probabilistic risk assessments pras. Human reliability assessment theory and practice crc press book a continually evolving discipline, human reliability assessment hra has elements of controversy from the definition of terms to the application of appropriate methods for the representation of human failure probability. The standardised plant analysis riskhuman reliability analysis method sparh 11,12,34 is built on an explicit informationprocessing model of human performance, derived from the behavioural sciences literature. The scope of this research is to identify the best suited human reliability analysis method for the volkerak sluice complex in the netherlands.
Human reliability analysis should identify and analyse all human actions and administrative controls that are necessary for safety. Optimising pifs will reduce the likelihood of human failure and increase human reliability. Human reliability analysis plays an important role in the total reliability analysis of a manmachine system. This research has been done in collaboration with rijkswaterstaat, the executive agency of the ministry of infrastructure and water. The starting point of this work was to study the framework of todays methods of human reliability analysis hra. Currently, no methodology has a general consensus, and most of them havent been very attractive to the media due to the complexity of the.
It is available to download for free by registering on the energy institute site. Methods of solving practical human reliability problems, the therp, slim, oat and sharp methods, performance shaping factors, human machine systems analysis, distribution of human performance and uncertainty bounds. Establishing the appropriate attributes in current human. Human reliability assessment hra involves the use of qualitative and quantitative methods to assess the human contribution to risk.
Considering the human failure as an integral part of a fault tree or event tree analysis. Dennis bley buttonwood consulting, roger boyer nasa, johnson space center, andreas bye institute for energy technology, norway, richard cook. It also assists with the application of other saps which set out expectations of a dutyholders fault analysis and human reliability analysis processes. Pdf this paper provides an overview of a comprehensive framework, corresponding set of techniques, and guidelines for performing hra analysis in. Reliability centered maintenance project managers guide. The book is organized into chapters, wherein chapter 1 presents histories of human factors and human reliability along with selective terms and definitions. Abstract human reliability analysis hra aims at identifying and analyzing possible human failures to perform safety. Human congnitive reliability model for pra analysis epri project rp 21703.
Human reliability program handbook what is the hrp. This document presents a shortened version of the procedure, models, and data for human reliability analysis hra which are presented in the handbook of human reliability analysis with emphasis on nuclear power plant applications nuregcr1278, august 1983. Accidents such as bhopal, three mile island, chernobyl, and piper alpha disasters are examples of human failures and show how catastrophic the consequences can be. The use of human reliability analysis hra to identify and resolve human factors issues has significantly increased over the past two years. Provides the uninitiated reader with a history of human reliability analysis, and includes actual examples of the application of the systems approach. Guttmann, handbook of human reliability analysis with emphasis on nuclear power plant applications, draft report for interim use and comment, nuregcr1278, washington, d.
19 1456 993 406 353 200 1505 157 1276 681 357 1553 855 866 368 1031 1174 572 991 318 1479 1014 690 169 55 85 981 1407 542 1010 993 257